This 1840s Captain’s Row historic home, known as “Pond View,” is a beautifully preserved example of classic Sag Harbor architecture, blending original granger elements with modern luxury. Located in Sag Harbor, this meticulously restored residence has housed notable figures including a composer, football icon, and ballerina. Featuring four bedrooms, three full baths, six fireplaces, a den/library, and an original 1840s fireplace/oven, the home offers rich history alongside top-tier amenities. Enjoy stunning western water views of Sag Harbor Cove and Otter Pond from multiple rooms. The grounds include a gunite plunge pool, lush landscaping, and private estate-like hedges. The listing price is $4,495,000.

Home Plan

The property layout shows a spacious historical home set on a large green lot with multiple outdoor areas including two main sitting/dining patios and a pool adjacent to a deck. The driveway accommodates several cars and leads to the main entrance. The house includes a first floor with a kitchen/dining room, den/library, living room, parlor/bedroom, and an entryway. The second floor contains three bedrooms including a primary suite and junior primary. Additional spaces include a basement and two attic levels, highlighting a blend of living, storage, and functional areas within 3,871 square feet of interior space.

Historic Home Exterior

Two-story structure clad in classic weathered cedar shingles with white trim accents the facade. The symmetrical window layout includes six-over-six pane double-hung windows, reflecting traditional craftsmanship. Decorative roof brackets and a triangular attic vent detail the gable, while the chimneys add historic character. The entrance showcases a bold blue door framed by pilasters and capped with an entablature, flanked by black lantern-style wall sconces. Manicured topiary bushes and vibrant pink hydrangeas enhance the well-tended front garden. A natural grass lawn and mature tree on the left side complete the picturesque, quintessential New England aesthetic.

Front Door Entrance

Centered royal blue front door framed by white pilasters and a transom window, adding classic charm to the historic facade. Cedar shingle siding in natural gray tones provides textured contrast. Two lantern-style black metal sconces flank the doorway, enhancing the traditional appeal. Symmetry is emphasized with two matching gray planters holding neatly trimmed round boxwood shrubs. The doorway is elevated by brick steps with stone treads, leading up to a stone landing. The landscaping features additional rounded boxwood bushes, creating a welcoming, well-maintained entryway with a blend of colonial and coastal influences.

Backyard Exterior View

A classic shingle-style house with weathered wooden siding painted in natural tones, framed by white trim around the windows and doors. The backyard features a manicured green lawn leading up to a raised wooden deck with stairs flanked by symmetrical potted pink flowering plants. French doors and multiple-pane windows punctuate the facade, allowing natural light to fill the interior. On the left side of the deck, cozy chairs and a small table create a relaxing nook, while on the right, an outdoor dining set provides space for gatherings. Mature trees and neatly trimmed hedges add to the serene and inviting atmosphere.

Backyard Deck and Spa

A raised wooden deck made of warm-toned planks with white trim leads to a charming backyard area. A small built-in spa with clear blue water sits alongside the deck, framed by a light-colored stone exterior wall. Two white wood chairs with blue cushions flank a slender table beneath a classic multilight window. A striped blue and white awning shades this seating nook. Doors with multiple glass panes open to the interior, framed by white trim. Lush greenery lines the perimeter, with blooming pink and red flowers adding vibrant natural color to the serene outdoor retreat.

Backyard Patio and Garden

A spacious grassy backyard leads to a charming elevated patio attached to a weathered shingle-style house. The patio is bordered by a stone foundation with steps ascending to a white wooden railing and multiple French doors. Two cozy seating areas with chairs and small tables invite relaxation amidst hanging potted flowers and garden blooms. The exterior boasts white trim contrasting the dark wooden shingles, supporting classic colonial craftsmanship. Decorative corbels accent the roofline and a half-moon window crowns the gable. Mature thrift and trimmed bushes frame the area, blending natural greenery with elegant design.

Back Door Entrance

White double doors with glass panes framed by a charming white wooden trellis canopy stand against a weathered wooden shingle exterior. The lattice design of the porch covering extends partially down the sides, creating a quaint garden nook. Climbing pale pink and white roses cascade over the top of the trellis, adding softness and a romantic touch. Surrounding the entryway, neatly trimmed green shrubs and mature trees enhance the lush, inviting atmosphere. The natural brown siding contrasts elegantly with the bright white trim, evoking a timeless and classic cottage aesthetic in this serene garden setting.

Entry Stairwell

A bright and elegant stairwell with historic charm characterized by its clean, classic lines and refined detailing. The staircase features white spindles and carved scrollwork on the risers, with contrasting black treads and handrail creating a timeless black-and-white palette. The walls are adorned with soft gray wainscoting topped by simple, narrow moldings, enhancing the architectural depth. Two vibrant, colorful paintings framed in gold add a pop of warmth and personality. A large window with divided lights and white shutters floods the space with natural light, complementing the light gray walls. A patterned gray carpet with black borders runs the length of the entry area, contributing texture and grounding the space in understated elegance.

Living Room Fireplace Wall

A classic living room corner with a central white fireplace mantel featuring detailed molding and fluted pilasters. Two elegant gold wall sconces with white shades flank a framed colorful artwork above the fireplace. Next to the fireplace, a polished black grand piano with golden caster wheels rests on polished wide-plank hardwood floors. On the left, two tall sash windows draped with cream curtains accented by Greek key patterned trim let in natural light, framing a wooden vintage cabinet stocked with spirits. The area rug has an intricate traditional pattern, coordinating with soft-toned, patterned upholstery on the curved lavender sofa. The walls are covered in neutral textured wallpaper, complementing the warm wood tones and gold decorative accents, including a sunburst mirror on the right wall.

Living Room Details

Wide doorway with blue-gray trim leads into a bright living room with large sash windows dressed in cream curtains. The soft lavender sofa anchors the seating area, complemented by a patterned area rug over warm, wide plank wooden floors. A deep teal sculptural chair adds bold color and texture, contrasting with antique wooden furniture pieces, including a secretary cabinet and sideboard. Elegant brass sconces and a framed artwork adorn the wall above a white panelled fireplace. A sleek black grand piano sits prominently, blending classic charm with a refined musical ambiance.

Sunroom Seating Area

A spacious sunroom bathed in natural light through multi-pane French doors and sidelights backs onto a garden view. Soft gray-blue painted walls and matching architectural trims create a serene, cohesive backdrop, complemented by a lustrous, reflective ceiling. Seating includes two blush velvet swivel armchairs with brass bases and a white upholstered sofa accented with geometric black and white pillows. A glass-topped coffee table with brass detailing sits centrally on a diamond-patterned area rug. Ornate fireplace with gray trim anchors one wall, flanked by decorative vases and sculptures. Framed paintings add warmth and character.

Living Room Fireplace Area

Soft gray walls and trim paired with a glossy white ceiling create a serene backdrop, accentuating the painted wooden fireplace mantel as a focal point. A crystal-clear glass and brass coffee table rests atop a patterned, grid-check carpet in neutral tones. Plush velvet chairs with golden bases bring subtle luxe touches while complementing the light sofa with blue geometric pillows. Through an open doorway, a bright sitting area with expansive windows floods sunlight across a grand piano and elegant curtains. Classic molding and wide doorway frames emphasize the historical yet refined architectural detail throughout the space.

Cozy Reading Nook

Built-in shelves painted in a muted beige line two walls, filled sparsely with books and decorative ceramics, creating an open yet curated atmosphere. A large L-shaped bench with deep navy cushioned seating and matching plush pillows offers ample space for lounging. The back wall incorporates textured grey paneling that adds subtle depth and contrast to the soft color palette. A vintage wooden chair with patterned upholstery is positioned by a bright window, which allows natural light to flood the space. The area rug features a diamond geometric pattern in neutral tones, complementing the brass-accented acrylic coffee table that adds modern flair. Mounted navy blue wall sconces provide soft, ambient lighting enhancing the nook’s tranquil vibe.

Cozy Reading Nook

A built-in, L-shaped banquette with deep navy cushions and patterned throw pillows anchors the space, inviting relaxation. Surrounding the seating are softly painted, pale sage-green wooden shelves and cabinetry with beadboard paneling for a subtle historic touch. The shelves hold a carefully arranged assortment of books, ceramics, and decorative objects adding personal character. Above, the ceiling features recessed coffered beams, enhancing architectural interest and depth. A textured, natural-fiber rug covers the floor, complementing the wood tones and muted wall covering behind the banquette that adds tactile warmth. Brass-accented wall sconces contribute soft lighting to the intimate setting. A clear glass coffee table with brass legs keeps the space open and sophisticated.

Kitchen Dining Area

Wide-planked wooden floors with a warm, weathered finish stretch throughout the kitchen dining area. A rustic wooden table painted soft green stands atop a traditional patterned rug, surrounded by mismatched chairs, some painted in pale sage green and others natural wood with woven seats. Exposed white ceiling beams complement the crisp white walls, enhancing the era-authentic cottage feel. A large row of mullioned windows floods the space with natural light, while a modern chandelier with black-shaded lights hangs above the table. A substantial black fireplace with a textured white plaster mantel creates a striking focal point and cozy atmosphere. Modern stainless steel appliances line the periphery, blending contemporary convenience with vintage charm.

Country Kitchen Dining Area

Wide, rustic wooden plank floors extend across the room, blending warmth with historic charm. Exposed white ceiling beams emphasize the vintage farmhouse aesthetic. A wooden dining table with a pale green base anchors the space, surrounded by mismatched wooden chairs, including a classic Windsor chair painted in a soft green hue. Above the table hangs a modern chandelier with black lampshades and brass accents, adding contrast. White cabinetry lines the kitchen area, topped with dark countertops. Stainless steel appliances, including a professional-grade range, complement the subway tile backsplash. An antique wooden cabinet stands against the far wall, adding character and storage.

Hallway and Staircase

This hallway presents a crisp, classic aesthetic with light grey paneling running along the walls, extending to the staircase. The stairs are painted white with dark grey treads and a matching dark banister, contrasting sharply with the lighter tones. The floors are warm natural wood with a long, patterned runner rug providing texture and warmth. A modern glass console table against the wall holds a decorative golden bust and a large, patterned lamp, while vibrant framed paintings add color and artistic flair above. The space ends with a softly arched doorway featuring a mural that adds historic character to the room.

Upstairs Hallway Landing

Light gray walls and white trim create a soft, neutral backdrop for this bright hallway landing at the top of a staircase. The black handrail and white balusters provide classic contrast and a polished historic touch. A crystal chandelier with leaf motifs hangs centrally, lending elegance and sparkle. Along the walls, framed colorful paintings inject character and warmth. A cozy bench with a muted patterned cushion offers a seating nook near a window that floods the space with natural light. A side cabinet and small table lamp contribute to the inviting, curated aesthetic of this transitional space.

Bedroom with Fireplace

A spacious bedroom painted in soft gray tones with white trim and crown molding creates a calm and airy atmosphere. The bed is large with a white comforter and a lavender patterned throw blanket, set against a textured accent wall. Two white closet doors flank the corner, allowing for ample storage. A floral-patterned armchair with wooden legs and arms sits next to a classic white fireplace featuring black bricks and stacked logs. Above the mantel, a vibrant seascape painting adds a pop of color. Natural light filters through a window with a neutral Roman shade, highlighting the room’s elegant simplicity and cozy charm.

Bathroom Vanity and Shower

A bright bathroom with a luxurious white marble theme dominates this space, extending from the countertop and walls to the floor. The double vanity has white cabinetry with gold hardware, complemented by gold faucets and matching rectangular mirrors framed in gold. Two vertical wall sconces with frosted glass are positioned between the mirrors, enhancing the warm brass accents. Exposed wooden ceiling beams add rustic charm contrasting the modern elegance. The large glass walk-in shower features gold fixtures, including a rainfall showerhead, and patterned tile flooring introduces subtle geometric interest, balancing the room’s classic and contemporary design elements.

Bedroom Interior

A soft, muted color palette fills the bedroom, dominated by soft gray walls and white wooden ceiling beams that emphasize a historic charm. The bed has an ornate vintage metal frame painted cream, complemented by white bedding with delicate floral embroidery. On either side of the bed, classic wooden nightstands hold traditional lamps with warm-toned shades, adding cozy ambient lighting. A large, gilded framed mirror rests against the wall, reflecting light and creating a sense of openness. Nearby stands an antique vanity table with an oval mirror and a matching chair, enhancing the room’s elegant, vintage atmosphere. Light blue Roman shades cover the double casement windows, offering a gentle contrast to the neutral tones and allowing natural light to fill the space. The woven sisal carpet adds texture and warmth to the floors, grounding the overall serene and inviting aesthetic.

Bathroom Shower and Sink

The narrow bathroom features white subway tiles on the walls extending into a glass-enclosed shower with a rain shower head. The floor is covered with a small, herringbone-patterned tile in soft gray tones. A classic white pedestal sink with brass fixtures sits beneath a rectangular mirror framed in brushed brass. Flanking the mirror are two vertical sconces with frosted glass shades, complementing the brass accents. A wall-mounted, extendable magnifying mirror adds functionality. White shiplap paneling runs midway up the wall, with brass towel bars holding crisp white towels and a robe hanging beside a black and white vintage beach photograph, adding a nostalgic touch. Exposed white beams overhead contribute to the bright, airy ambiance.

Bedroom with Fireplace

A serene bedroom with soft gray walls and white trim highlights the historic charm. The wide plank wooden floor adds warmth and character. Three large sash windows with white patterned Roman shades bring in natural light and offer views of greenery outside. A classic white fireplace mantle with fluted pilasters serves as the room’s focal point, topped with a colorful abstract seascape painting and four elegant brass candlesticks. The bed is dressed in crisp white linens and a textured navy quilt, with deep blue pillows adding subtle contrast. Simple wooden furniture complements the tranquil, refined ambiance.

Historic Bathroom Details

The bathroom features a vintage clawfoot bathtub with ornate feet, paired with an overhead brass shower fixture and a white curtain. Adjacent is a classic pedestal sink with brass faucets, lending an old-world charm. Above the sink hangs an intricately carved wooden mirror that enhances the room’s antique appeal. Two brass wall sconces with cream shades flank the mirror, providing balanced lighting. The walls are partially paneled and adorned with a detailed hand-painted mural depicting a serene sailing scene framed by lush greenery and flowers, adding a soft, pastoral ambiance embraced by a muted palette of pale blues and greens.

Listing Agent: Marc Heskell – Associate Real Estate Broker of Compass via Zillow