This 1840s Captain’s Row historic home, known as “Pond View,” in Sag Harbor, beautifully blends original granger architecture with modern luxuries. Meticulously restored, it has hosted luminary owners from the arts and sports worlds. Featuring four bedrooms (one a parlor), three full baths, a den/library, and six fireplaces, the home boasts striking western views of Sag Harbor Cove and Otter Pond. The kitchen highlights an original 1840s fireplace/oven alongside Viking and Sub-Zero appliances. The estate includes a gunite heated plunge pool, lush landscaping, and private 8′ Ilex hedges. Listed at $4,495,000, this residence offers seamless indoor-outdoor living with rich historical character preserved throughout.

Home Plan

The floor plan highlights a classic layout with multiple defined spaces. The Kitchen/Dining Room spans over 21 feet by 17 feet, adjoining a Sitting/Dining Area that leads to a 23 by 12-foot deck with a pool beside it. The central Living Room, 12 by 21 feet, is marked by a fireplace dividing it from the kitchen area. The left side holds a Parlor Room or fourth bedroom with its own fireplace, emphasizing a traditional design. On the right, a Den/Library and a bathroom with closets add private utility and convenience. The 7’9” by 19’ entry includes staircase access and a closet, providing a welcoming yet functional foyer.

Backyard Exterior

Natural wood shingles cover the entire rear facade, aged gracefully to give a timeless and rustic appeal. Symmetrical placement of white-framed windows and a central French door with glass panels open onto a wooden deck. The deck, adorned with potted pink flowering plants, extends a few steps down to lush, green lawn. Outdoor seating areas include a small casual bistro set on the deck and a larger dining table on a gravel section, ideal for entertaining. Trim details at eaves and corners subtly enhance the classic cottage look. Mature greenery and a manicured hedge frame the garden space.

Backyard Patio and Pool

A cozy backyard patio with a small rectangular pool bordered by modern stone and a clean ledge. Warm wooden steps lead up to a deck clad in natural-toned wood planks. The exterior wall of the house has weathered wooden shingles that give a historic, rustic charm, complemented by white-framed windows and French doors featuring multi-pane glass panels. A navy-and-white striped awning shades the seating area, which consists of two white wooden chairs with cushions and a small curved metal table. Lush greenery and blooming pink and red flowers add vibrant color and invite tranquility.

Backyard Patio and Garden

A lush green lawn stretches across the backyard, bordered by neatly trimmed hedges and mature trees. The home’s exterior showcases weathered cedar shingles complemented by white trim and classic multi-pane windows. A raised stone foundation supports a cozy patio area, furnished with white chairs and a small table, perfect for outdoor relaxation. French doors with glass panes open onto the patio, inviting natural light inside. The stairway with white railings leads down to the garden, which is accented with colorful flowering plants in terracotta pots and a well-manicured surrounding garden that enhances the serene and timeless aesthetic of the historic residence.

Garden Entrance Canopy

White lattice wood frames a small entrance door, creating a quaint canopy that extends outward providing a charming shelter. Soft pink roses climb and weave through the lattice roof, adding romantic floral beauty and a touch of natural elegance against the rustic brown cedar shingle siding. The entrance door features glass panels and a brass knob, exuding vintage appeal. Surrounding the structure are verdant green shrubs and mature trees with thick foliage, contributing to a lush, inviting garden atmosphere that complements the classic American historic architectural style.

Front Entrance Doorway

The entrance is marked by a vivid blue door framed with classic white trim and sidelights featuring multi-pane glass, enhancing natural light. Two traditional black lantern-style sconces flank the doorway, adding a timeless charm. The exterior walls are clad in weathered cedar shingles, providing a rustic, coastal aesthetic. Symmetrically placed large potted boxwood shrubs sit on a slate-tiled stoop, which is accessed by brick and stone steps. This arrangement exudes a welcoming, refined colonial style with balanced proportions and attention to detail in both landscaping and architecture.

Staircase Entryway

A charming entryway with a classic staircase displaying white spindles and a black handrail that curves gracefully at the base. The stair risers are accented with delicate scrollwork, enhancing the historic character. Walls feature light gray wainscoting panels topped with a soft neutral paint, harmonizing with the white trim and window moldings. Two colorful, framed paintings bring a welcoming splash of vibrancy to the wall beside the stairs. The window includes white plantation shutters halfway up, allowing diffused natural light to filter in over a patterned carpeted floor with a diamond motif bordered by black trim, blending elegance with warmth.

Living Room Fireplace Area

Soft gray textured walls harmonize with wide-plank honey-toned wooden floors, creating an inviting yet refined ambiance. A classic white mantel surrounds a modern gas fireplace, flanked by elegant brass sconces casting warm light. Above the fireplace, a vibrant framed painting adds a splash of color, complemented by another framed artwork and a radiant sunburst mirror on adjacent walls. Floor-to-ceiling cream drapes with Greek key trim frame double-hung windows, allowing natural light to brighten the room. A plush lavender sofa with patterned pillows faces a Persian-style rug. An antique wooden sideboard holds an impressive bar setup, while a gleaming black grand piano adds sophistication and artistic charm.

Living Room Entrance

Through wide, classic blue-gray painted door frames with brass keyhole details, a bright living room is visible. The space offers polished wooden plank flooring complemented by a traditional patterned rug. Soft, neutral-toned walls contrast with a lavender upholstered loveseat, accented with pastel pillows. Two large sash windows with cream-colored drapes on antique brass rods invite natural light, framing views of greenery outside. A black grand piano and a deep teal, textured armchair introduce deep hues and a hint of luxury. On the left, an antique wooden cabinet with curved edges adds historic charm, balancing the modern artistic and light fixture accents.

Living Room Details

The living room presents a serene palette of soft grays and creams, with walls, trim, and ceiling painted in a lustrous pale gray. The room is anchored by a traditional fireplace with detailed molding, flanked by two small statues and topped with a framed landscape painting. Floor-to-ceiling French doors at the far end flood the space with natural light, enhancing the airy atmosphere. Plush velvet swivel chairs with gold bases and a white sofa adorned with navy-patterned pillows create a cozy seating area around glass-topped, gold-framed coffee tables. A checked carpet covers the hardwood floor, complementing the refined aesthetic of this elegant historic space.

Living Room with Fireplace

Soft gray walls and trim frame the living room, blending classical architectural elements with modern comfort. A detailed fireplace mantel stands as a focal point, topped with a framed landscape painting and a small sculpture. Two plush swivel chairs with brass bases and a curved sofa offer inviting seating around a round glass coffee table with brass accents. A patterned rug anchors the space, complementing the neutral palette. Through the wide doorway, a black grand piano and additional seating create a harmonious flow, while large windows fill the room with natural light and outdoor views.

Cozy Reading Nook

A corner seating area with built-in cabinetry and open shelving wrapping around two walls. The cushioned seating is upholstered in rich navy fabric with coordinating throw pillows adding texture and comfort. The walls behind the seating are covered in a subtle textured wallpaper in cool tones, enhancing the cozy atmosphere. A wooden chair with intricate woven details and patterned cushion adds warmth and contrast. Light filters through tall windows with bamboo blinds, brightening the space. A clear acrylic coffee table with brass accents and a large woven rug with geometric patterns ground the area, blending modern and traditional styles.

Cozy Reading Nook

A built-in bench with deep blue cushions anchors this cozy nook, surrounded by floor-to-ceiling cabinetry painted in a soft, muted gray. Cushions and throw pillows, in varying shades and patterns of blue, add texture and comfort. The cabinetry above and around includes open shelving with books and decorative objects alongside closed storage, creating an organized, functional space. The ceiling is coffered and painted white, enhancing the classic architectural detailing. The textured woven rug in neutral tones grounds the seating area. Brass-accented glass coffee table adds a modern touch to the traditional palette and design.

Dining Area with Fireplace

Wide wooden plank flooring with natural grain and marks anchors the space, complementing a rustic, large dining table with a muted green base and natural wood top. The seating consists of a mix of painted and natural wood chairs in a farmhouse style, adding an eclectic touch. White-painted exposed ceiling beams and abundant natural light pouring through several multi-pane windows create an airy and bright atmosphere. A substantial fireplace with a whitewashed textured chimney and dark gray mantel offers a cozy focal point. Modern stainless appliances and a black granite countertop contrast subtly with the historic elements. A patterned rug beneath the table adds warmth and color, blending old-world charm with contemporary comfort.

Kitchen Dining Area

Wide plank wooden floors with a natural warm finish cover the space. Beamed ceilings painted white create a textured yet bright atmosphere. The dining table, painted soft green, pairs with mismatched wooden chairs, including a turned spindle back chair painted in a complementary muted green. A Persian-style rug anchors the dining area. White cabinetry lines the right wall, topped with dark granite countertops, contrasting the light walls. A substantial stainless steel range and hood blend professional-grade appliances with rustic charm. Brass fixtures, such as the gooseneck faucet and the chandelier with black shades, add warmth and historic character. Walls are painted pale gray, enhancing the airy ambiance, while an antique wooden armoire adds depth and vintage appeal.

Entry Hall Stairs

A bright and elegant entry hall with a staircase ascending on the right, featuring black-topped white wooden steps and classic white balusters. The walls are adorned with white wainscoting and a soft gray paint above, giving a refined and historic feel. A patterned runner carpet covers the light wooden floor along the hallway. On the left side, a glass console table holds a gold bust sculpture and a modern lamp, while large framed artworks with vivid colors decorate the walls. The doorway at the hallway’s end opens to a mural of a coastal scene, enhancing the hallway’s artistic charm and depth.

Upstairs Hallway

A bright upstairs hallway with soft neutral gray walls and white trim accentuates the classic architectural details like the ornate molding along the stairwell. The wooden banister is painted black on the top with white balusters creating a striking contrast. A sophisticated crystal chandelier hangs from the ceiling, adding elegance and sparkle. The floor is covered with a patterned gray runner that leads to a cozy seating area with a wooden settee upholstered in coral fabric and decorative pillows. Large, vibrant artwork in red and warm tones brings bold color to the space, harmonizing with natural light from the window. A small antique console table with a lamp sits against the back wall, enhancing the historical charm.

Bedroom Fireplace Area

A spacious bedroom with soft gray walls and matching built-in closets with classic paneling surrounds the space. A large bed with pristine white bedding and a purple geometric patterned throw rests against a textured accent wall. Near the fireplace, an upholstered wooden armchair with a nature-inspired leaf pattern sits next to a vintage-style brass floor lamp. The fireplace has a white classic mantel and a black brick firebox filled with stacked birch logs. Above it, a vibrant ocean wave painting adds contrast and color, highlighting the room’s serene and inviting ambiance.

Bathroom Vanity and Shower

White marble tiles cover the walls and floor, with the floor tiles featuring a subtle geometric pattern near the shower area. A spacious double vanity in crisp white cabinetry stands beneath two rectangular mirrors framed in elegant gold, matching the gold fixtures and hardware throughout. The light fixtures beside each mirror echo the gold motif, adding warmth and sophistication. Exposed rustic wooden beams contrast gently with the sleek marble and glass elements. The glass shower enclosure has gold hinges and handles, maintaining coherence with the vanity’s metallic accents, creating a luxurious and polished atmosphere.

Bedroom Interior Details

This bedroom blends a soft, calming color palette with rustic and vintage elements. The walls are painted a muted light gray, complementing the beige woven carpet flooring. Exposed whitewashed wooden beams on the ceiling add a farmhouse charm. A classic metal bedframe with intricate detailing holds bedding in white and pastel floral patterns, emphasizing a delicate, airy feel. On either side of the bed, elegant table lamps stand on an antique wooden side table and a small round table, providing warm lighting. A large ornately framed golden mirror leans against the wall beside a dainty vintage vanity with an oval mirror, adding character and depth to the space. Windows dressed with muted blue Roman shades allow natural light to highlight the serene, timeless atmosphere.

Bathroom Details

The bathroom is designed with a clean, vintage-inspired aesthetic combining white subway tiles and beadboard paneling in a bright, airy space. A glass-enclosed shower with matching tiled walls and a herringbone marble floor adds texture and elegance. The pedestal sink is traditional, paired with brushed brass fixtures and dual vertical sconces flanking a rectangular mirror. Antique brass towel bars and a mounted magnifying mirror complement the hardware theme. The exposed white painted ceiling beams bring character, while a framed black-and-white photograph adds a nostalgic, personal touch reflecting historic charm.

Bedroom with Fireplace

Natural light floods the room through three tall windows dressed with soft, patterned Roman shades that add subtle texture. The walls are painted a calming light gray, contrasting beautifully with the warm, wide plank wood flooring that evokes timeless charm. A classic white mantelpiece surrounds the fireplace, topped with elegant brass candlesticks and a framed painting adding a touch of color and artistry. The bed features pristine white bedding with a textured blue throw blanket that complements the blue pillows and adds cozy sophistication. A simple wooden chair and a small corner chair near the window complete the serene, historically inspired bedroom ambiance.

Bathroom Vanity and Tub

A pedestal sink with brass faucet fittings stands beneath an ornate, antique wooden-framed mirror. Flanking the mirror are two brass sconces with cream lampshades. The wall showcases a soft pastel mural featuring lush greenery, blooming flowers, and a sailing ship on the water, evoking a vintage, coastal atmosphere. To the right is a classic white clawfoot bathtub with an overhead circular shower curtain rod and a crystal-accented showerhead, adding elegant historic charm. Pale gray walls and wooden floorboards with a woven rug complete this serene and artful bathroom corner.

Cozy Basement Lounge

Exposed rustic wooden beams and uneven wood ceiling boards create an authentic historic ambiance. The brick fireplace with a dark wooden mantel is the room’s focal point, flanked by two vintage leather armchairs with well-worn patina and colorful cushions. A large, plush sofa with patterned fabric in muted cream and red tones softens the space. Whitewashed stone walls enhance the basement’s aged character. A built-in dark wooden bar with stools sits beneath a wide mirror, reflecting light and expanding the sense of space. The brick floor, neutral rug, and subtle decorative elements like plants and candles complete the warm, inviting aesthetic.

Listing Agent: Marc Heskell – Associate Real Estate Broker of Compass via Zillow