A Beautiful 1928 Rustic Estate in Brookhaven, New York

Written By

Mathew Abraham

Updated on

Mathew Abraham

Mathew Abraham, editor of Century Homes America, brings his passion for architectural history to explore the stories behind America’s most iconic homes.

Tour This 1928 Rustic Vernacular Estate in Brookhaven, New York
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

Set on 2.75 acres of preserved land, this 1928 rustic retreat offers a rare opportunity to own a historic estate in Brookhaven, New York. Spanning 4,000 sq. ft., the property features three distinct homes, blending timeless craftsmanship with a natural setting. With seven bedrooms and 4.5+ baths, it provides ample space for private living or a family compound. The estate includes The Marsh House, a working greenhouse, and multiple outbuildings, adding to its charm. Surrounded by federal land, this $1.9 million property is a nature lover’s dream, offering a serene escape in one of Long Island’s most scenic locations.

Aerial View

Aerial View
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

Spanning acres of pristine landscape, this secluded estate offers privacy and natural beauty. A winding waterway flows through the property, enhancing its serene atmosphere. Surrounded by dense woodlands, the home sits nestled within nature, creating a peaceful retreat. The expansive land provides opportunities for outdoor living, while the meandering water adds a tranquil touch to the breathtaking scenery.

Where is Brookhaven, New York?

Where is Brookhaven, New York?
Bing Maps

Brookhaven, New York, is a charming and historic hamlet located on the south shore of Long Island. Surrounded by preserved land, scenic waterways, and lush woodlands, Brookhaven offers a serene retreat with a deep connection to nature. Known for its rich history, organic farms, and coastal beauty, the area boasts a peaceful lifestyle while maintaining easy access to New York City. Home to wildlife refuges, marinas, and historic estates, Brookhaven embodies a perfect blend of rustic charm and exclusivity, making it an ideal destination for those seeking tranquility and timeless elegance.

Backyard

Backyard
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A timeless shingle-clad home with a screened porch and aged wood siding, exuding charm. Towering trees frame the house, their bare branches adding to the rustic appeal. Weathered details hint at the home’s storied past, blending effortlessly with the natural surroundings. The cozy structure embodies a historic character, making it a peaceful haven surrounded by nature’s raw beauty.

Cozy Cottage

Cozy Cottage
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

This quaint cottage welcomes visitors with its warm wooden exterior and bright red door. Large windows bring in natural light, while ivy-draped trees add a sense of seclusion. A perfect retreat, it embraces simplicity and nature in equal measure. Its rustic charm and timeless appeal make it an ideal countryside hideaway, blending effortlessly into the wooded surroundings.

Lakeside Cabin

Lakeside Cabin
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A charming wooden cabin perches on the edge of the water, blending into the golden marshland. Its aged wood exterior and cross-braced gables evoke a sense of nostalgia. Surrounded by tall reeds and open skies, it offers a quiet refuge by the lake. The gentle ripples of water reflect the ever-changing seasons, making it a serene escape into nature.

Entryway

Entryway
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

Rustic wooden beams and large glass panes fill this space with sunlight and warmth. Handmade sculptures and natural elements create an artistic, lived-in feel. The doors open to reveal a tranquil retreat where creativity and nature meet. This thoughtfully designed space invites reflection, with the blend of craftsmanship and organic elements forming a one-of-a-kind workspace.

Sunlit Workshop

Sunlit Workshop
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

This hand-crafted workspace features exposed beams and an open-air design. Sunlight streams through the slanted glass roof, casting shadows on the worn wooden floor. A space for craftsmanship and reflection, it blends function with rustic beauty. Every detail, from the repurposed wood to the natural light, contributes to an inspiring environment that fosters creativity and connection with nature.

Window View

Window View
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A striking arched window with intricate latticework draws the eye. Its delicate tracery and pointed arch nod to gothic architecture, adding character to the space. The soft natural light highlights the rich wood tones and historic craftsmanship. Set against a backdrop of lush greenery, the window becomes a timeless focal point, blending artistry with architectural grandeur.

Kitchen

Kitchen
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A bright and airy kitchen with vaulted ceilings and exposed wooden beams. Floor-to-ceiling bookshelves and a rustic island create a cozy, lived-in feel. The gothic window above the sink offers picturesque views while adding a touch of old-world charm. The open layout and natural wood tones bring warmth, making it a welcoming and functional space.

Scenic Balcony

Scenic Balcony
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A handcrafted wooden balcony overlooks golden marshes and endless blue skies. Weathered railings and rustic furniture invite quiet moments of reflection. A perfect place to soak in the beauty of the untouched landscape. The expansive view stretches beyond the horizon, allowing nature’s tranquility to become an essential part of everyday life in this secluded retreat.

Loft Space

Loft Space
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A cozy loft space with reclaimed wood walls and bold accent colors. Handcrafted details, from the distressed cabinets to the vintage-inspired door, tell a story of the past. Natural light pours in, creating a warm and inviting retreat. The exposed wooden beams and rustic furnishings add depth and authenticity, making this loft an intimate escape filled with timeless charm.

Workspace

Workspace
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

This handcrafted workspace features reclaimed wood, a vintage industrial desk, and exposed beams. The combination of natural materials and worn finishes creates a timeless setting filled with character. Sunlight filters through the space, highlighting the aged patina of the wooden surfaces. It’s a room designed for creativity, offering a quiet and inspiring environment for work and reflection.

Handcrafted Laundry

Handcrafted Laundry
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

This cozy laundry space blends function with rustic craftsmanship. Exposed wood beams, custom-built cabinetry, and iron railings add depth and character. A deep farmhouse sink sits beneath a large window, allowing natural light to brighten the space. Built-in shelving and unique curved details create a warm and inviting atmosphere, making even the most practical space feel charming and intentional.

Open Kitchen

Open Kitchen
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

Vaulted ceilings and exposed wooden beams create an airy and inviting kitchen space. A large farmhouse sink, butcher block countertops, and custom cabinetry bring a rustic charm. Floor-to-ceiling windows flood the room with natural light, offering views of the surrounding landscape. The open layout encourages gatherings, while the natural materials add a sense of warmth and authenticity to the space.

Wooden Archway

Wooden Archway
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A sculptural wooden archway welcomes guests into the property, blending seamlessly with the natural surroundings. The twisted branches and handcrafted details create a whimsical yet organic entrance. Beyond the arch, a serene landscape unfolds with an open field, a tranquil pond, and scattered trees. This artistic gateway embodies the home’s rustic charm and connection to nature.

Sink Nook

Sink Nook
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A rustic utility nook designed for both function and charm. The deep farmhouse sink sits beneath a broad window, framed by warm-toned wood panels. Custom-built shelving and aged wood accents create a practical yet beautiful space. Sunlight pours in, highlighting the rich textures and natural imperfections of the materials, making the space feel welcoming and lived-in.

Sunlit Entryway

Sunlit Entryway
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

Large glass windows and doors flood this entryway with natural light, seamlessly blending the indoors with the outdoors. The rustic wood detailing, exposed beams, and handcrafted railing create a warm and welcoming feel. The transition from the kitchen to the outdoors is smooth, making this space ideal for entertaining. A thoughtful mix of natural tones and textures enhances the home’s timeless appeal.

Living Room

Living Room
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

A bright and airy loft space with vaulted ceilings and reclaimed wood details. A vintage cast-iron stove sits in the corner, offering warmth and a nostalgic touch. The custom-built bookshelves and intricate wooden beams give the room a handcrafted feel. Sunlight filters through the arched window, adding a soft glow to the honey-toned floors and highlighting the space’s unique architectural elements.

Weathered Doorway

Weathered Doorway
Anthony Gandolfo, Rice Realty Group

This weathered wooden doorway opens into a space filled with handcrafted details and natural textures. The aged wood, exposed rafters, and rustic hardware add a sense of history. Sunlight streams through the windows, casting warm shadows across the textured walls. The entrance exudes a sense of nostalgia, inviting visitors to step into a place where past and present beautifully intertwine.

Listing agent: David Rice @ Rice Realty Group, Inc.

Related Posts

After signing his landmark $330 million contract with the Philadelphia Phillies, Bryce Harper put down roots in Haddonfield, New Jersey, with a $2.6 million farmhouse that blends luxury, privacy, and family-focused design. The property reflects both the demands of a superstar athlete and the practical choices of a growing household.
The modest Los Altos house where Steve Jobs grew up and where the first Apple I computers were assembled has been formally recognized as a historic site. Its designation reflects both Apple’s humble beginnings and the growing importance of preserving technology history.
Chris Brown has repeatedly identified Michael Jackson as the defining influence on his career, pointing to the pop legend’s artistry, stagecraft, and direct praise as formative moments in his rise. That connection helps explain both Brown’s performance style and the lasting cultural weight of Jackson’s legacy.
LeBron James continues to live in a striking Brentwood estate that blends elite security, family-focused comfort, and resort-style amenities. The nearly 16,000-square-foot property reflects the scale of his career and the practical demands of life beyond the NBA spotlight.
Before Hollywood made Quentin Tarantino famous, he says his real education happened behind the counter at Video Archives in Manhattan Beach. The store gave him a vast cinematic library, a forum for sharp debate, and the confidence that later defined his directing voice.
Ricky Stenhouse Jr. has sold his 140-acre Mooresville estate, Slide Job Ranch, for a record $12.2 million, setting a new high for residential sales in the Charlotte metro area. The deal highlights both the strength of luxury property demand around Lake Norman and the singular appeal of a NASCAR-ready country compound.
Wayne Gretzky’s former Westlake Village estate overlooking Sherwood Country Club sold for $17.6 million, underscoring the enduring appeal of celebrity-owned luxury homes in Southern California. The 6.69-acre property blends privacy, resort-style amenities, and the polished lifestyle buyers expect at the top end of the market.
In one of Hollywood’s strangest true stories, director Werner Herzog came upon Joaquin Phoenix after a violent 2006 car crash and calmly guided him out of danger. The moment became legendary not just for the rescue, but for Herzog stopping Phoenix from lighting a cigarette near leaking gasoline.
Matthew McConaughey’s story begins in small-town Texas, where family, school, and local values helped form the voice and identity he later carried to Hollywood. From Uvalde to Longview to Australia, each stop added a layer to the actor the world came to know.