This charming 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home, built in the early 1800s, showcases the classic Sag Harbor architectural style with its simple, timeless design. Located in the heart of Sag Harbor village, it offers approximately 2,000 square feet of sunlit living space on a generous 0.44-acre lot. The home’s historical significance lies in its embodiment of early village life, nestled close to shops, beaches, restaurants, and a marina. Priced at $3,250,000, this property balances historic charm with modern living, featuring a spacious yard perfect for outdoor entertaining. Recent renovations have enhanced its natural light and preserved its classic features, maintaining its century-old allure.

Entry Hallway with Staircase

A bright entry hallway painted in crisp white creates an inviting atmosphere, accentuated by a rich black handrail that adds contrast to the white wooden staircase. The staircase features detailed spindle balusters, maintaining a classic historic charm. A small wooden side table with turned legs holds a clear glass vase filled with dried pampas grass, introducing natural texture. The floor is covered by a dark patterned runner rug, providing depth against the white floorboards. An ornately carved wooden door opens into a formal dining room seen beyond, where dark wood chairs surround a polished table beneath a colorful framed painting. A vintage, geometric chandelier hangs overhead, giving a subtle nod to historic craftsmanship.

Dining Room Details

A classic dining room with a set of six tall, dark wood chairs surrounding a matching wooden dining table. The floor is covered with an intricate blue and white patterned rug, adding warmth and texture to the space. The walls and ceiling are painted white, creating a bright, airy feeling. A vintage-looking chandelier with ornate metalwork hangs above the table, adding an antique charm. Against the back wall, a white fireplace mantel serves as a focal point, topped with a vibrant, colorful painting that contrasts with the otherwise subdued color palette, injecting artistic flair.

Dining Room and Adjoining Sitting Area

The dining space centers around a richly carved dark wood table paired with intricately detailed chairs and a matching bench with a high, sculpted back. A blue and cream patterned rug anchors the furniture on white painted plank floors, adding warmth and vintage charm. Light filters gently through softly sheer white curtains on tall windows, brightening the crisp white walls. An ornate dark metal chandelier hangs overhead, echoing the antique aesthetic. Adjacent, a cozy sitting area contains a leather settee and small tables, framed by large windows and a wooden grandfather clock, blending historic elements with comfort.

Living Room and Entry

Bright, airy living room with white walls and whitewashed wooden floors creating a clean, minimalist backdrop. Two leather sofas with rich brown wood frames add warmth and classic texture to the space. A modern black chair with a wood frame contrasts yet complements the traditional furniture. Central oval glass-top coffee table with wooden legs and a lower shelf holds books and decorative pieces, resting on a plush white area rug. Through a wide doorway, a formal dining area features a wooden table and intricately carved chairs beneath a vintage chandelier, alongside a colorful abstract painting over a white mantel. A staircase with white risers and black handrail is partially visible, framed by a dark wood glass-paned door.

Living Room Details

A warm, inviting living room with a blend of vintage and modern aesthetics. A rich brown leather sofa is complemented by a soft, fluffy white throw. The space is dominated by a white fireplace mantle with intricate detailing, surmounted by a painting of a boat on calm waters. To the left, two large, ornately framed stained glass windows add historic charm with deep amber and blue hues. A sleek wooden coffee table with a glass top holds books and decorative objects, set upon a plush, light-colored rug. Accent pieces include a pottery vase with dried pampas grass, a sculptural torso in a niche, a leafy potted plant, and a modern black and wood lounge chair, all framed by white walls and soft natural light from large windows.

Kitchen Dining Nook

A bright, cozy dining nook adjacent to the kitchen stove area is presented with a clean, white-walled ambiance highlighted by beadboard paneling on the walls and ceiling. The corner features a built-in window bench adorned with soft cushions in floral and yellow tones, complemented by hanging greenery that adds a refreshing natural touch. Four white wooden chairs with natural wood legs surround a simple, streamlined white table placed on a textured natural fiber rug, enhancing warmth and earthiness. Stainless steel appliances, including a microwave and stove with a kettle, frame the nook, blending modern utility with cottage charm. Soft white curtains diffuse natural light, creating an inviting and airy atmosphere.

Kitchen with Fireplace

Bright kitchen painted entirely in white, including paneled walls, ceiling, and floor, creating a crisp, clean atmosphere. Two natural fiber rugs add warmth and texture underfoot. A white brick fireplace, painted to match the walls, serves as a charming focal point beside the white refrigerator. Simple white chairs and a small dining table are positioned near a window and a door with glass panes that invite natural light. A contemporary black ceiling light fixture with exposed bulbs contrasts the otherwise traditional style. Visible through the open doorway is an adjoining living room with period wood furniture and soft lavender walls.

Cozy Bedroom with Fireplace

A spacious bedroom with soft white walls and a low, slanted ceiling creating an intimate atmosphere. A large bed with sage green bedding and a white plush throw is centered on a thick, textured area rug in muted taupe. At the foot of the bed stands a wooden bench featuring a chevron pattern adding warmth to the pale flooring. A classic white fireplace with a black interior occupies one wall, accented by a round mirror resembling a ship’s wheel and nautical decor on the mantel. Natural light floods through a large window near a wooden armchair with cream cushions, balancing comfort with minimalism. A dark wood dresser topped with a TV completes the room, blending modern living with rustic charm.

Bathroom Shower Area

The shower area is lined with glossy white subway tiles creating a clean and bright atmosphere. The showerhead and controls are modern chrome fixtures, complementing the minimalist design. A large window with multiple panes provides natural light and a scenic view of greenery outside. Adjacent to the shower, the space extends into a bathroom area with a white vanity topped with marble, accompanied by a wicker-framed mirror adding a rustic yet elegant touch. Light wood storage cabinets with slatted doors hold neatly folded towels, reinforcing the room’s tidy and well-organized aesthetic. The overall color scheme is soft white and natural wood, enhancing a fresh, airy feel with subtle warmth.

Bedroom with Twin Beds

Two twin beds positioned against angled walls indicate a cozy attic or upper-floor bedroom. The white walls and ceiling create a bright and airy feel, while the exposed white-painted brick chimney adds a touch of rustic charm. Bedding with blue and white stripes complements the similarly striped rug, reinforcing a nautical or cottage-inspired theme. Natural light filters in through a small window with sheer curtains. A wicker chair and minimalistic side tables with vintage-style lamps contribute to a simplistic yet inviting atmosphere. A muted abstract painting adds a soft splash of color and texture.

Bedroom with Desk Nook

White walls and ceiling create a bright, airy atmosphere enhanced by natural light filtering through sheer, cream-colored curtains on two windows. A patterned rug with rich greens, blues, and touches of orange adds warmth and character, contrasting with the minimalist decor. A wooden desk with a traditional design sits in the corner, paired with a modern gray swivel chair. The bed, dressed in crisp white bedding, anchors the space on one side. A large mirror leaning against the wall and a landscape painting add depth and subtle artistic touches to this serene and uncluttered bedroom.

Bathroom Vanity and Tub

A bright bathroom with white shiplap walls and ceiling delivers a fresh, airy atmosphere. The centerpiece is a white vanity with paneled cabinet doors and a matching drawer, topped with a simple sink and chrome faucet. Above it hangs a large, ornately framed mirror painted white, adding a touch of vintage elegance. A small vase with white flowers and a dark candle provide subtle decoration on the countertop. Natural light streams in through a single window, illuminating the space. To the right is a white bathtub with a chrome rain showerhead and a striped white-and-blue shower curtain, complementing the clean, coastal-inspired design. The flooring is a gray wood-look laminate, softly contrasting the predominantly white decor while still maintaining the serene vibe.

Cozy Bedroom Corner

Soft natural light filters through sheer grey curtains hung on a tall window, enhancing the room’s airy, minimalist ambiance. A white bed with a textured comforter and plush pillows dominates the foreground, complemented by a cozy cream throw. A wooden bookshelf filled with books stands to the left, while a full-length mirror leans casually against the wall near a small cushioned stool with a book atop. A dark wood TV stand with a flat-screen television sits below the window. On the opposite wall, a modern grey dresser holds plants and decorative items beneath a framed colorful painting, all set against crisply painted white walls and crown molding.

Listing Agent: Charles Forsman – Real Estate Sales Person of Compass via Zillow