Built in 1925, a historically significant Key West residence, blending classic island architecture with modern luxury. Located on a prestigious Old Town corner, the home features striking rooflines, expansive porches, and large verandas that define its timeless style. Handmade Dade County pine floors, original windows, and a beautifully preserved staircase portray its rich heritage. Recently restored from foundation to rooftop, the home combines historic charm with modern amenities, including custom cabinetry and elegant finishes. The property boasts three en suite bedrooms, a private pool courtyard, a detached guest cottage, and rare off-street parking with an electric gate. Listed at $4,100,000, it captures refined island living with utmost sophistication in Key West.

Historic Home Exterior

This historic home is characterized by a classic Southern architectural style with multiple gabled metal roofs. White wooden siding and a spacious front porch with detailed railings create a welcoming façade. The property is fenced with a white picket fence, and surrounding lush greenery, including palm trees and shrubs, adds to its tropical ambiance. A small rectangular pool sits prominently in the front yard amidst well-maintained hedges and plants. The red brick driveway to the right contrasts the white exterior, completing the charming and inviting exterior of the residence.

Exterior Front View

A crisp white historic American home with a metal roof reflecting bright sunlight, giving a fresh and clean appearance. The two-story structure is characterized by classic clapboard siding, multi-pane windows, and a charming picket fence enclosing a small, neatly trimmed hedge-lined garden. A brick driveway adds a warm, textured contrast to the white exterior. Lush tropical plants and palm trees flank the home, enhancing the coastal or southern charm. The upper-level porch with white railings presents an inviting spot for relaxation. The overall aesthetic conveys timeless elegance with a beachside cottage vibe blending nature and architecture harmoniously.

Backyard Patio and Pool

A charming backyard with a clean, white wooden paneled house featuring a covered porch and a second-story balcony, both adorned with classic spindle railings. The ground-level porch has a small dining set, ideal for outdoor meals. A brick pathway winds through vibrant green artificial or well-maintained grass, guiding past tropical palm trees towards a compact, elegant pool with clear water and decorative tile steps. A small whimsical statue sits at the pool’s edge, adding character. Adjacent is a cozy lounging area with a bright orange hammock and white sun loungers, blending comfort with historic architectural charm under a bright blue sky.

Outdoor Porch and Balcony

White wooden two-story exterior with a spacious covered porch on the ground floor and a matching covered balcony above. The porch includes a small white table and chairs, perfect for casual outdoor seating. Classic spindle railing on the balcony and beneath the elevated porch add historic charm. Light gray painted ceiling of the porch and balcony contrasts softly with the bright white structure. Surrounded by lush palm trees and vibrant green lawn with brick path walking alongside the house toward a private backyard space. A small pool and sculptural fountain are visible on the right, enhancing the tranquil, tropical ambiance.

Front Porch Entrance

A classic front porch painted in soft white with gently grooved wooden siding creates a welcoming entryway. The double front doors are rich dark wood with glass panes, allowing views through to the interior and bringing natural light inside. A white picket fence encloses the area, leading to three broad steps up to the porch. Symmetrically placed on either side of the door are sculpted topiary plants in ornate stone planters, adding sophistication. Two black lantern-style wall lights flank the door, complementing the green foliage that frames the porch, lending an elegant yet homey historical charm.

Living Room Details

Natural wood-paneled walls in warm tones envelop this cozy living room, paired with a white ceiling featuring exposed beams and recessed lighting. Large windows with textured Roman shades flood the space with natural light, highlighting the neutral and earthy color palette. Comfortable cream-colored sofas face a rustic wooden coffee table adorned with natural decor pieces, while an antique wooden sideboard supports a wall-mounted TV. Two accent chairs with a playful, vintage-inspired pattern inject character and warmth. A green adjustable desk lamp on a side table, a classic ceiling fan with dark wood blades, and greenery add touches of charm and life to the room.

Cozy Sitting Room

The room features a warm combination of natural wood paneling on three walls and a white shiplap ceiling with recessed lighting. The floor is wide plank wood, enhancing the rustic feel. Two neutral-toned cushioned sofas face each other, complemented by two armchairs with an Asian-inspired print adding subtle pattern and charm. A dark round side table with glass top and a lighter wooden coffee table in the center anchor the seating area. Windows dressed with woven blinds let in natural light, while a ceiling fan with wooden blades centers the space. A wooden cabinet under a mounted TV and leafy green plants bring in more organic warmth. Soft, muted wall art and a green desk lamp on a carved wooden side table add softened elegance.

Dining and Living Room

A warm, inviting open-concept space blending the dining area with a cozy living room. The room features rich, honey-toned wood flooring and a striking wood-paneled accent wall behind the living room seating, which contrasts beautifully with the crisp white walls and ceiling. A rustic wooden dining table dominates the foreground, complemented by upholstered chairs in a soft neutral palette. Above, a vintage-inspired chandelier with black lampshades adds character and warmth. The staircase, painted white with wood railings, adds architectural interest with a small door built into its base. Natural light filters in through two windows framed with Roman shades. An area rug with intricate patterns lies near the entrance, completing the classic yet comfortable aesthetic.

Dining Area and Kitchen Bar

This space includes a rustic dining area adjacent to a kitchen bar with three stools. Warm, honey-toned wooden floors and a wood-paneled wall add natural texture, contrasting with crisp white trim and cabinetry. The dining table is wooden with four upholstered cream-colored chairs. A decorative chandelier with multiple candle-shaped lights and black shades hangs above the table, contributing elegance. Woven blinds soften the abundant natural light from multiple windows. A framed monochrome artwork adorns the wood-paneled wall near a set of white French doors with semi-sheer curtains. The overall aesthetic balances cozy farmhouse charm with subtle sophistication.

Kitchen and Dining Area

White cabinetry with classic panel detailing runs along the kitchen walls, paired with gray stone countertops adding a modern contrast. A farmhouse-style sink sits below a window fitted with woven wood shades, allowing natural light to filter in softly. Warm wood planks clad the walls around the kitchen peninsula, which doubles as a breakfast bar with matching stone countertop. Pendant lights with wicker shades hang from the ceiling beams, complementing the natural textures. The open layout extends into a dining area with upholstered chairs and a chandelier, all resting on polished hardwood floors that bring warmth and continuity to the space.

Kitchen Interior Details

A bright U-shaped kitchen with polished wooden flooring enhances the warm, inviting atmosphere. White traditional cabinetry with silver hardware combines with dark gray granite countertops for a sophisticated contrast. Multiple windows with natural woven shades allow ample light, creating an airy feel. The wall-mounted open shelves and spice rack add functional charm to the space. Pendant lights with basket-style shades add rustic warmth above the counters. A decorative carved wooden corbel holding pottery is mounted above one window, emphasizing a blend of classic and farmhouse elements. Stainless steel appliances provide modern convenience.

Bedroom with Balcony Access

A spacious bedroom with warm honey-toned wooden plank walls and matching hardwood flooring. A large brass four-poster bed with white bedding and accented pillows serves as the focal point. Flanking the bed are light-colored side tables with ceramic lamps that add a touch of classic charm. The vaulted white ceiling complemented by a wooden ceiling fan contributes to airiness and comfort. On one side, glass French doors open fully to a private balcony overlooking lush greenery and a pool, inviting natural light and outdoor connection. Soft green curtains frame the doorway, enhancing the tranquil, coastal-inspired ambiance. A textured gray area rug anchors the bed, adding subtle contrast and warmth to the room.

Backyard Pool Area

A compact, rectangular pool serves as the centerpiece of a serene backyard retreat, bordered by a lush, manicured lawn. Light gray stone tiles outline the pool’s perimeter, complementing the clear blue water and mosaic tile steps inside. Adjacent to the pool stands a charming white porch with light railings and double French doors that lead into a bedroom with a neatly made bed. The exterior walls of the home are clad in classic white siding, maintaining a clean and timeless aesthetic. Surrounding the area, tall green hedges provide privacy, while palm trees above add a tropical touch.

Master Bedroom View

A vaulted ceiling painted white enhances the spaciousness of this master bedroom, combined with warm wooden floorboards. A brass four-poster bed with white linens anchors the room, complemented by patterned throw pillows adding subtle color and texture. The bed’s headboard is set against a natural wood accent wall that brings warmth and a rustic touch to the otherwise neutral palette. A floral upholstered armchair sits in the corner beside a light wood dresser topped with a flat screen TV. Track lighting and a wooden ceiling fan provide modern functional elements, while framed artwork adds personality.

Bathroom Vanity and Shower

Two sleek vanities with light wood cabinetry support crisp white countertops, both equipped with modern chrome faucets and rectangular sinks. Above each vanity hangs a large, simple mirror complimented by a streamlined light fixture, lending a contemporary touch. A window with white plantation shutters permits natural light, balancing the room’s neutral palette. The adjoining walk-in shower features large gray tiles with subtle texture and a geometric mosaic tile floor, enclosed by a frameless glass panel. Smooth rich hardwood flooring adds warmth, creating a clean, inviting space where modern elegance meets functional design.

Bedroom with Balcony

A bedroom with a vaulted white shiplap ceiling housing a dark wood ceiling fan contrasts with the warm natural wood-paneled accent wall behind the bed. The bed frame is a detailed vintage style with woven cane panels in a soft gray finish, paired with crisp white bedding and a floral tapestry accent pillow. Natural light fills the room through a small window on the wood wall, covered with a simple woven shade, and an open door leading to a spacious balcony with white railing, framed by palm trees outdoors. Hardwood floors and a patterned rug add texture and warmth to the space.

Bedroom Balcony Access

Light gray shiplap walls and ceiling contrast with a rich honey-toned hardwood floor. The vaulted ceiling enhances spaciousness, complemented by a wooden ceiling fan with vintage finishes. A large bed features an ornate headboard with cane detailing, paired with a floral tapestry pillow adding subtle color and texture. Two windows with woven wood shades flank the bed, while a set of French doors opens to a covered balcony overlooking lush palm trees, merging indoor and outdoor living. Heavy gray curtains provide privacy and softness to the room, blending rustic and coastal aesthetics.

Sunroom and Balcony

A cozy sunroom with polished hardwood floors and white walls opens onto a spacious covered balcony through a set of white-framed French doors. The balcony is adorned with traditional spindled railings and painted in a light neutral tone. Inside the sunroom, natural light filters through double windows fitted with woven brown roman shades that add texture and warmth. A vintage wooden dresser stands beneath the windows, topped with decorative bookends and a ceramic lamp. The ceiling is simple and painted white, complementing the overall light, airy, and classic coastal aesthetic. Outside, lush green palm trees add vibrant natural color and a tropical vibe.

Covered Porch

A spacious covered porch with light beige wooden flooring and white balustrades lining the perimeter. The ceiling beams are painted in a soft pale blue, adding a subtle coastal touch. Classic French doors with multiple glass panes open to the interior, framed by horizontal siding walls also painted cream-white. A single wicker chair sits near the railing, facing lush tropical greenery and palm trees visible beyond the porch. A black vintage-style wall lantern mounted beside the door adds an elegant, timeless charm to this airy, light-filled outdoor space.

Bathroom with Walk-in Shower

White walls and subway tiles create a crisp, clean environment balanced by a warm wood vanity with a white countertop. The mirror has rounded corners and is framed in a thin black border, reflecting a soft white pendant light above. A polished silver faucet and matching toilet paper holder add elegant metallic accents. White towels neatly stacked on a rustic bronze towel rack complement the color scheme. The walk-in shower features a glass half-wall and door, with vintage brass shower fixtures and natural stone tile flooring, blending classic and modern styles.

Upstairs Hallway

A narrow hallway upstairs lined with warm, natural wood paneling on one side, contrasting with smooth, white-painted walls on the other. The hardwood floor is partially covered by a richly patterned, traditional runner rug in shades of red, brown, and blue. A wooden banister with classic turned spindles and a rounded newel post adds a traditional architectural detail. Soft lighting from wall sconces and track lights illuminates the space. Three windows with natural woven blinds allow ample daylight. Two large, framed abstract artworks hang on the wood-paneled wall, while a decorative mirror and small ceramic object rest near the doorway leading to a bedroom beyond.

Bedroom with Wood Accent Wall

Natural wood paneling covers the main wall behind the bed, accentuating the room’s warmth and rustic charm. The ceiling and opposing walls are painted crisp white, creating a bright and airy atmosphere contrasted by the rich wood tones and honey-hued floorboards. A tufted gray upholstered headboard adds a soft, elegant texture to the space, complemented by two floral patterned pillows. Matching wooden nightstands flank the bed, each topped with classic lamps. Above the bed hangs a colorful, lively painting that draws the eye upward, enhanced by a window near the vaulted ceiling for extra natural light. French doors with glass panels open to a balcony, inviting the outdoors in. Neutral window shades and a ceiling fan with wooden blades complete the room’s balanced blend of traditional and contemporary aesthetics.

Bathroom Details

A compact bathroom with a clean and bright aesthetic, featuring a white toilet situated against light, horizontally-paneled walls. Warm, natural hardwood flooring contrasts softly with the white fixtures. A recessed shower area with white subway tiles is accompanied by a brass showerhead and modern gray patterned curtain. The vanity has a light wood finish, topped with a smooth white countertop and integrated sink, accented by classic brass faucets. A large, rounded rectangular mirror hangs above the countertop, flanked by a pair of elegant wall sconces with white shades that add warm ambient lighting to the space.

Backyard Patio and Pool

A quaint backyard patio with a small, rectangular plunge pool bordered by stone tiles sits adjacent to a white wooden house with classic American colonial architectural elements. The porch has white balustrades and French doors opening into a bedroom featuring a visible bed and soft lighting from a bedside lamp. A lush green hedge provides privacy next to the pool, while a red brick pathway runs alongside the pool, leading to a white picket fence gate. Tropical palm trees and clear blue sky add a bright, serene, and inviting atmosphere to the outdoor space.

Front Porch Entrance

Small covered front porch with classic white wooden railings and balusters welcomes visitors. The porch is accessed by brick paver walkway, bordered by white picket fencing on either side, providing a quaint and charming entry. The structure is predominantly white with horizontal siding that enhances the historic cottage style. Two symmetrical windows flank the central French door that opens inward into the house, allowing natural light to enter. Lush green tropical plants and palm trees in the background contrast with the white exterior, adding a refreshing, lively ambiance to the space. The porch ceiling has recessed lighting, combining traditional charm with subtle modern touches.

Sunroom Seating Area

A cozy sunroom with vaulted ceilings painted white contrasts with a warm rustic wood-paneled accent wall surrounding a glass door leading outdoors. Two plush, beige velvet armchairs with earth-toned accent pillows face each other near a wooden dresser holding a ceramic table lamp. A large, intricately patterned cream and brown area rug covers polished wooden floors. Natural woven shades dress the three adjacent multi-pane windows, allowing ample sunlight to filter in. Elegant framed bird illustrations in gold frames line one wall, complementing the room’s combination of traditional and cottage aesthetics, creating a serene, inviting atmosphere.

Cozy Kitchen Nook

White shiplap walls and ceiling create a bright, airy atmosphere contrasted by a rich wood accent wall framing a glass door and two windows, inviting natural light. The hardwood floor complements the warm wood tones, harmonizing with the rustic dining table and matching chair. The kitchen island with smooth white cabinetry and a quartz countertop includes a modern sink with a sleek faucet. Above, a ceiling fan with wooden blades and track lighting provide functional illumination. Soft accents like the patterned rug, earth-toned armchair, botanical artwork, and floral centerpiece add charm and warmth to the space.

Kitchen and Dining Nook

Compact kitchen with crisp white cabinetry and polished stainless steel appliances including a refrigerator, oven, and microwave. A white countertop peninsula extends with a built-in sink, creating a small breakfast bar. Warm wooden flooring contrasts against the white walls and ceiling with horizontal paneling, evoking a cottage-like charm. A unique, ornate lantern-style pendant light hangs, adding character. A detailed model ship atop the refrigerator adds nautical interest, complementing the beachy, historic vibe. Adjacent is a rustic wooden dining table with spindle-back chairs, adorned with patterned placemats. The warm, inviting space opens towards a hallway leading to other rooms.

Bedroom Corner

The space exhibits a cozy bedroom corner with white horizontal paneling covering the walls and ceiling, creating a bright and airy ambiance. A four-poster bed with an ornately carved wooden frame is upholstered with a delicate golden-yellow damask fabric, adding vintage charm. White bedding contrasts softly against the detailed headboard. Balanced on either side, carved wooden wall-mounted shelves serve as nightstands, each topped with simple, elegant white lamps. A wooden ceiling fan with dark blades adds warmth and practical airflow. A single window with a woven bamboo blind introduces natural light and texture, complementing the warm tones of the polished wood floor.

Bathroom Interior

Soft cream shiplap walls frame a compact bathroom with a classic white vanity and a chrome faucet. Above the sink, a rectangular mirror with a bamboo-style wooden frame adds a natural touch. A metal towel rack holds plush white towels above the toilet, which is modern and streamlined. On the adjacent wall, a framed artwork with pastel floral and bird motifs complements the space with subtle color. A glimpse of the shower reveals glossy teal-blue subway tiles and a clear glass door with chrome fixtures, blending contemporary elements with cozy, understated elegance.

Listing Agent: Team Kaufelt of Truman & Co. (KW) via Zillow