Situated on the historic Millionaire’s Row in Old Town Key West, this beautifully restored century home blends classic charm with modern luxury. The main residence showcases Dade County pine walls, high ceilings, and natural light, featuring four ensuite bedrooms and a versatile downstairs suite. The estate includes a newly built guest house with vaulted ceilings and top-tier Miele appliances. Central to the compound is a lush tropical garden with a saline pool, waterfall, and outdoor shower, crafted by renowned landscape architect Craig Reynolds. Priced at $6,300,000, this rare Key West property offers off-street parking and impeccable design for distinguished island living.

Backyard Pool Area

Clear blue pool water gently shimmers under natural sunlight, bordered by a smooth stone pool deck. The shallow entry steps gradually descend into deeper water, creating a welcoming ambiance. A row of cushioned chaise lounges lines one side of the pool, perfectly set for relaxation. Lush tropical greenery surrounds the perimeter, including tall palm trees enhancing the tranquil, resort-like atmosphere. A charming white house with a wrap-around porch and French doors stands at the far end, blending classic coastal architecture with modern comfort. Outdoor seating on the porch invites leisurely gatherings amid serene natural surroundings.

Outdoor Pool Area

A lush tropical ambiance surrounds a rectangular swimming pool with a shallow ledge area, perfect for lounging in the water. The pool deck is paved with light beige stone tiles that complement the vivid blue water. Multiple cushioned lounge chairs are neatly arranged along the top edge, each accompanied by small round side tables. The space is framed by dense greenery, including tall palms and thick bushes, creating a secluded, private oasis feel. The combination of natural green foliage and clean, modern pool design evokes a tranquil, resort-like atmosphere.

Front Yard and Exterior

White picket fence encloses a lush, tropical front yard filled with various palm trees and dense greenery, creating a vibrant, verdant ambiance. The historic house exterior is painted in white with black shutters flanking the windows, adding classic contrast. A steeply pitched metal roof and gabled windows suggest traditional architectural influences. The driveway beside the house holds a red vehicle, partially visible behind the fence. The porch includes two wicker chairs, suggesting a cozy sitting area beneath the overhang. Sunlight filters through the foliage, casting dappled shadows on the sidewalk and fence, enhancing the inviting charm of this historic American home.

Front Porch Seating

Raised front porch with light grey wooden flooring bordered by intricately designed white railing. Two dark woven high-back chairs accented with cream cushions and patterned lumbar pillows sit beside a small round table. White siding with black shutters frames a rich wooden doorway, flanked by two classic black lantern-style wall sconces. The porch ceiling is painted a traditional sky blue, while brick steps lead down to a brick-paved pathway surrounded by lush green foliage including a large fan palm. The space exudes Southern charm with clean lines and a cozy, inviting aesthetic.

Front Porch Seating

White wooden porch floor and decorative railings with intricate cutouts create a charming historic aesthetic. Comfortable black wicker seating with light cushions and patterned pillows invite relaxation. Large hanging lanterns in a matte black finish add elegant lighting suspended from the pale blue ceiling. The porch overlooks lush tropical greenery, including palms and shrubs, contributing to a serene and inviting atmosphere. A brick pathway alongside the garden enhances the quaint outdoor appeal, while the light pastel blue siding of the house complements the natural surroundings and classic design elements.

Backyard Pool and Lounge

A serene backyard area centered around a rectangular swimming pool with a light sandy-colored deck. The pool is surrounded by lush tropical greenery including various palm trees and dense bushes, creating a private oasis feel. On one side, comfortable outdoor seating includes cushioned lounge chairs and a striped cushioned sectional sofa with throw pillows, arranged around small round tables. At the far end, a pathway leads to a charming, classic American-style house with a pitched roof painted in muted gray tones. The overall atmosphere is tranquil, inviting relaxation amid natural elements and subdued earthy hues.

Backyard Pool Area

Lush tropical foliage, including large palm leaves and dense greenery, frames a serene backyard pool area. The swimming pool has clear blue water surrounded by pale stone tiles, creating a bright and inviting space. Several comfortable lounge chairs and a rocking chair with cushioned seats are arranged around the pool. The backdrop includes a white two-story house with black shutters and a covered porch furnished with additional seating. The design blends tropical landscaping with classic American farmhouse elements, emphasizing relaxation, natural beauty, and refined outdoor living.

Living Room with Staircase

This living room exudes a warm and inviting ambiance with a neutral, soft color palette dominated by beige walls and light wood flooring. A cozy U-shaped seating area with patterned gray and cream couches and armchairs surrounds a glass coffee table adorned with decorative items. The white-painted ceiling hosts recessed lighting and a ceiling fan for comfort. The staircase features a striking combination of white spindles, a natural wood handrail, and wooden steps, complementing the warm wooden panel accent wall beneath the stairs. French doors with glass panels invite natural light and connect to an outdoor space. Subtle artistic accents and a woven basket add texture and character to the well-balanced room.

Dining Room and Entryway

A long, rectangular dining table dominates the space, surrounded by cushioned chairs dressed in soft beige slipcovers. The room flows seamlessly with natural light pouring through French doors at the far end, revealing a vibrant outdoor garden. Light wood flooring with natural grain adds warmth, contrasting subtly with the cream-colored walls and white crown moldings. Two patterned armchairs sit near the doors, complementing the neutral tones. A modern ceiling fan and a classic chandelier blend utility and style overhead. Built-in shelving with decorative items and a wall-mounted TV contribute to a cozy yet sophisticated atmosphere, adjacent to the kitchen entrance.

Bedroom with Window View

A vaulted ceiling with exposed wooden beams contrasts with the white ceiling, creating a spacious and airy atmosphere. The walls are covered in a textured, muted green wallpaper that adds a natural, calming vibe. The centerpiece is a large wooden bed frame in a distressed gray finish, topped with neatly arranged neutral-toned bedding featuring subtle patterns and various textured pillows. Flanking the bed are two dark wooden nightstands, each with a stylish lamp. A wide open window framed by thick beige curtains reveals lush greenery outside, enhancing the room’s serene ambiance. Light wood flooring and a patterned area rug complete the look.

Kitchen and Living Area

The kitchen island with a smooth white countertop is complemented by five dark wood stools with patterned cushions. Behind the island, deep brown cabinetry contrasts with a colorful, vintage-style tile backsplash in soft blues and creams, bringing an artistic element to the space. A window over the sink allows natural light, framed by classic white molding. The living area adjacent holds neutral-toned sofas and armchairs, accented with throw pillows and framed botanical and anatomical art on the wall. A black metal railing loft accessed by a narrow ladder adds vertical interest, beneath vaulted white ceilings with exposed beams and dual chandeliers that combine rustic and elegant charm.

Living Room Stairway

The stairway wall is adorned with warm, horizontal wooden planks contrasting with the crisp white trim and staircase base. The banister’s black handrail atop white spindles adds a classic touch. Hardwood flooring flows throughout the space, complementing a muted rug that anchors the seating area. A patterned armchair with a greenish accent pillow sits adjacent to a cozy sofa covered in textured, earth-toned cushions. A round pedestal table under the stairs holds a traditional lamp and decorative vase, enhancing the nook’s charm. Light walls and ample natural light contribute to the room’s inviting, refined ambiance.

Cozy Living Room Corner

Soft beige walls surround this intimate living area, highlighted by white trim with subtle decorative molding that evokes classic architectural charm. A plush gray sofa adorned with patterned and plain throw pillows sits beneath a window fitted with a light wood blind, inviting natural light. The space is anchored by a patterned area rug under a rectangular wooden coffee table with black metal framing. A textured armchair with a cozy throw and pillow complements the seating arrangement. Art featuring birds adds warmth above a side table topped with a lamp and a small potted plant, enhancing the serene, inviting atmosphere.

Dining Room and Kitchen Entry

A long, rectangular wooden dining table topped with a decorative tray and candles is surrounded by eight high-back chairs, each covered in a soft, grayish-striped fabric with slipcovers reaching the floor. Above the table hangs a large, black metal chandelier with candle-style lights, adding a modern farmhouse touch. The white ceiling contains built-in recessed lighting and a white ceiling fan. Hardwood floors run throughout the space, providing warmth and contrast to the neutral-toned walls. Adjacent to the dining room, a wide kitchen entry features classic white cabinetry and built-in shelves with decorative items, seamlessly connecting the spaces. Through the glass door at the far end, a glimpse of a lush outdoor garden with a seating area and pool is visible, adding an inviting open-air extension to this elegant room.

Dining Room Detail

A spacious dining room with a long wooden table surrounded by eight upholstered chairs with tailored slipcovers in a muted earth tone. Two wingback chairs with patterned upholstery and accent pillows sit at the far end by large French doors, allowing abundant natural light and a view of lush greenery outside. Light hardwood floors and neutral beige walls complement the classic white trim and crown molding. A large rectangular lantern-style chandelier hangs above the table, flanked by ceiling fans for comfort. Built-in shelving and cabinetry on one side display decorative items, providing functional elegance and a cozy, inviting atmosphere.

Kitchen and Living Room Entry

A sleek kitchen cabinetry unit painted in soft white with black handle accents holds a built-in Miele microwave and spacious storage drawers. To the left, a tall Sub-Zero wine fridge with glass and wood shelving adds modern sophistication. The light wall color complements the warm honey-toned hardwood floors extending into the adjacent living space. The open doorway framed with detailed white molding reveals a living room with patterned armchairs, a large gray sectional sofa, and art pieces on pale walls. A wood staircase with white spindles and a dark handrail rises beside the entryway, blending classic architectural details with contemporary furnishings.

Kitchen Countertop and Sink

The kitchen has an elongated layout with pristine white cabinetry featuring dark handles, topped with smooth marble countertops extending along both sides. A sleek, modern gas stove with red knobs is embedded on the left countertop, while the right side hosts a deep stainless steel sink beneath a set of windows fitted with woven blinds, allowing natural light to brighten the space. Hardwood flooring adds warmth, complemented by patterned rugs running the length of the kitchen. White paneled walls and trim, recessed lighting, and an open doorway leading to a sunlit outdoor seating area enhance a bright, airy atmosphere with subtle coastal charm.

Galley Kitchen

A narrow galley kitchen with cream-colored cabinetry on both sides, featuring sleek metallic handles and smooth white countertops. Polished hardwood flooring runs the length of the kitchen, complemented by a long, patterned runner rug adding subtle texture and warmth. Recessed ceiling lights provide bright, even illumination. Stainless steel appliances, including a large refrigerator and built-in oven, contribute to a modern aesthetic, while a small window above the sink allows natural light to enter. The kitchen opens toward a cozy seating area framed by a glass door, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor living flow.

Cozy Bedroom Corner

Soft beige walls and a vaulted white ceiling with exposed planks create a bright, airy atmosphere. A white ceiling fan hangs overhead, complementing the light decor. The bed has a uniquely shaped, white wooden headboard and is adorned with patterned pillows and a cozy quilt in muted tones of gray, white, and pastel colors. Two windows behind the bed have neutral pleated shades, allowing filtered natural light. A weathered wooden nightstand sits beside the bed, topped with a white ceramic lamp and accent items, harmonizing with the rustic wooden dresser on the left. Natural wood flooring adds warmth to the serene space.

Cozy Bedroom Interior

A serene bedroom with a vaulted white ceiling and a white ceiling fan that enhances the airy atmosphere. The walls are painted in a soft beige, complementing the warm wood flooring. A large bed with a white headboard stands at the center, dressed in a striped quilt with shades of white, black, and gray, accented by multiple patterned pillows in neutral and mustard hues. Matching wooden nightstands flank the bed, each topped with a lamp and decorative items, while the windows are framed with white trim and fitted with woven roll-up blinds, adding texture and natural warmth. A glimpse of an adjoining bathroom with neutral tiles and dark cabinetry completes this blend of traditional and cozy aesthetics.

Laundry Closet

A compact laundry space reveals a modern stacked washer and dryer unit with chrome-trimmed circular doors, nestled within a deep niche. The doors leading to this area are white with horizontally slatted panels, offering both ventilation and a clean aesthetic. Walls are painted in a soft neutral tone, complementing the light wood flooring that runs through the connected hallway visible beyond the laundry door. The adjacent room, partially seen, has a light-colored area rug with subtle patterns and a glimpse of a dark-finished cabinet or dresser against a wall, enhancing the warm, inviting atmosphere of the home.

Bedroom Interior

High vaulted ceiling with exposed wooden beams and a white ceiling fan create a spacious feeling. The walls are covered in a neutral textured wallpaper, complementing the light gray and white color palette. A large wooden bed frame with intricate posts supports a king-sized bed dressed in coordinated white and gray patterned bedding, layered with multiple decorative pillows. Flanking the bed are two dark wood nightstands adorned with classic lamps and decorative objects. Window treatments include soft gray curtains and neutral blinds, allowing glimpses of lush outdoor greenery through multiple windows, adding a tranquil natural ambiance to the room.

Bathroom Shower Area

White subway tiles cover the walls throughout, including the shower enclosure, creating a clean, bright aesthetic. The walk-in shower features clear glass panels with a half wall and a modern dual shower head system. A small recessed niche is built into the shower wall for toiletries. The vanity has a rich dark wood base with a smooth white marble countertop that incorporates subtle gray veining. Polished chrome fixtures add an elegant touch. Warm-toned hardwood flooring contrasts with the white tile, introducing warmth to the room. Louvered double doors create a textured detail, while recessed lighting ensures a crisp, inviting atmosphere.

Kitchen with Loft Access

Long kitchen layout with dark wood cabinetry lining both sides contrasts elegantly against bright white marble countertops. The right wall is adorned with intricate tile backsplash in blue, white, and beige geometric patterns surrounding a white framed window with blue blinds. A rustic chandelier hangs from the high vaulted ceiling featuring exposed white beams, balancing vintage charm with modern touches. At the kitchen’s end, a wooden ladder leads up to an airy loft area decorated with baskets and textiles, overlooking a cozy seating nook with a grey sectional and framed art on soft cream walls. Warm honey-toned wood floors extend throughout.

Attic Bedroom

A cozy attic bedroom with a vaulted ceiling featuring exposed white-painted beams and plank detailing. Two twin beds are positioned on either side of a central wooden chest with a rustic finish. The bed linens and pillows display soft neutral tones and subtle patterns that complement the light gray walls. A small window centered between the beds is adorned with a simple gray Roman shade. Decorative items including framed artwork, a red painted horse sculpture, and a few small lamps rest on the ledges formed by the knee walls, contributing to a charming, homey atmosphere. The warm wooden floorboards add natural texture and balance the predominantly white and muted color scheme.

Attic Loft Seating Area

Sloping white-painted wooden beams create a vaulted ceiling with distinct triangular framing. The floor consists of polished natural wood planks that add warmth to the crisp white surroundings. A black metal railing runs along the open edge, providing a clear view of the room below while ensuring safety. Two cushioned poufs with textured patterns in cream and black offer cozy seating at the loft’s edge. To the right, a rustic wooden cabinet holds board games and decor items. The space combines modern minimalism with rustic charm, enhancing the home’s airy, inviting atmosphere.

Master Bedroom with Patio View

Dark wood four-poster bed with intricate twisted carvings anchors the room, adorned with textured bedding in muted beige and patterned pillows in soft greys and blues. Two matching bedside tables, each with drawers and lower shelves, support contemporary lamps with fabric shades. Neutral-toned walls frame two windows with woven beige roman blinds. Hardwood floors are partly covered by a textured, light grey rug. Ceiling fan with light hangs centrally. French doors open onto a covered patio featuring lush greenery and black wicker chairs, blending indoor comfort with outdoor nature seamlessly.

Bedroom Details

A softly painted bedroom with light gray walls and white crown molding presents a timeless, serene atmosphere. The centerpiece is a dark wood four-poster bed with intricately turned posts, topped with patterned beige and cream bedding accented by coordinated pillows. Two windows flank the bed, draped with textured Roman shades, offering balanced natural light. Each side of the bed holds a classic, dark wooden nightstand with a simple lamp, adding warmth. A large, circular wooden wall art piece with a sunburst effect adds rustic charm. Hardwood floors, topped with a muted gray area rug beneath the bed, complement the calming, sophisticated aesthetic.

Listing Agent: Brenda J Donnelly of Brenda Donnelly Real Estate LLC via Zillow