The Fogarty House, Bradenton’s oldest documented residence, has been saved from the brink of demolition due to strong community effort and now stands proudly as an officially designated historic landmark. Built in 1871 by the skilled Fogarty brothers, renowned local boat builders, this three-story, five-bedroom home showcases exceptional craftsmanship and a rich piece of Florida’s heritage. Under the careful stewardship of its current owner, Dr. Hal Ott, the house has undergone a thoughtful restoration that preserves its original character and structural integrity.

Historic Home Under Threat

The 154-year-old Fogarty House faced imminent demolition after a developer showed interest in the property. Dr. Hal Ott spotted the “for sale” sign and feared the loss of a vital piece of Bradenton’s history. Motivated by this, he purchased the home to ensure its preservation rather than letting it be bulldozed.

Meticulous Restoration Efforts

General contractor Davy Windham took on the challenging task of restoring the house, which involved stripping it down to the studs and lifting it 10 feet. This complex process required precision and care, which Windham attributes to “the Lord being with us,” given the difficulties involved.

Craftsmanship of the Fogarty Brothers

Built by Captain Bartholomew “Tole” Fogarty and his brothers—master boat builders from the local Fogartyville community—the house’s construction is notable for its exceptional quality. Windham praised the original craftsmanship, noting how well the structure has held up over nearly a century and a half.

Unique Architectural Features Discovered

During renovation, Windham discovered an unexpected “wall of multi-colors,” created unintentionally as a result of the Fogarty brothers’ habit of repurposing lumber salvaged from storm-damaged ships. This reclaimed wood adds a distinctive artistic quality to the home’s interior, highlighting the boat builders’ resourcefulness.

Preserving Original Details

Special attention was given to maintaining original elements such as doors, wood paneling, and glass inserts. Both Ott and Windham emphasized their commitment to preserving these authentic features, which contribute significantly to the home’s historic character.

Community Pride

Ott expressed deep pride in the collaborative effort that saved and restored the Fogarty House, calling it “a treasure.” Nearly a year of work with the Manatee County Historical Society culminated in the installation of a permanent iron historical marker in front of the home, drawing public attention to its cultural and architectural importance.

Current Status and Value

Located at Riverview Boulevard in Bradenton, the three-story, five-bedroom Fogarty House is currently listed for $1.9 million. Its designation as a historic landmark and careful restoration make it a unique and valuable piece of Florida’s heritage, attracting interest from those who appreciate its rich history and craftsmanship.