Located in Port Jefferson, “The Cottage” is a majestic English Country Estate built around 1906. Originally the private residence of Ralph Peters, former President of the Long Island Rail Road, this 5,800 square foot home sits on an expansive 3.85-acre waterfront plot with 530 feet of private beachfront. The estate masterfully blends historic early American craftsmanship with modern luxury, featuring diamond-pane windows, exquisite millwork, and a grand open concept room with a two-story atrium. The 8-bedroom, 4.5-bath residence offers stunning harbor views and extensive outdoor amenities, including terraces and a sun deck. Listed at $4,490,000, it is a rare North Shore landmark where heritage meets waterfront elegance.

Historic Home Exterior

Two-story classic American home painted in soft blue with white trim and decorative brackets under wide gabled eaves. Symmetrical façade with diamond-pane windows and a charming second-floor balcony featuring detailed balustrades and bracket supports. The lower level displays arched window frames with brick accents between them. A stone retaining wall and stairway lead to a paved pathway bordered by manicured shrubs and garden beds. The setting is tranquil, surrounded by tall leafless trees, suggesting early spring. Architectural details highlight a blend of Craftsman and traditional styles, evoking a timeless and inviting presence.

Driveway Entrance

A gently curving asphalt driveway lined with a narrow border of cobblestones leads up a slight incline through a wooded area with tall, leafless trees. There is a prominent white wooden signpost on the right side near the road’s edge, featuring a dark plaque with the address “10 Pine Path.” The trees cast long shadows over the driveway, reflecting an early spring or late autumn setting. In the distance, a glimpse of a classic, historic home with light-colored siding and a steep roof adds charm, inviting visitors through this peaceful and secluded natural approach.

Garage Exterior

A quaint detached garage nestled into a slight hillside, painted in a soft, muted gray with white trim that accentuates its clean lines. The white garage door has a classic carriage-house style with crossbuck detailing and small, multi-pane windows along the top. Above the door, a trio of small diamond-paned windows set in white frames add character and light. A black metal lantern hanging in the center enhances the vintage charm. Surrounding leafless trees and patches of ivy climbing some trunks evoke a serene, natural setting, emphasizing a peaceful and timeless ambiance.

Front Porch Entrance

Wide front porch with muted gray painted wooden flooring and classic white columns featuring decorative paneling. The entrance door is crafted from rich wood with intricate stained glass and a carved lion motif at the bottom. A woven basket with fresh flowers hangs on the door, adding a natural and welcoming touch. Flanking the door are two traditional black lantern-style wall lights. An American flag mounted on the right adds a patriotic element. A small white statue of a sitting dog rests next to a simple natural fiber doormat, complementing the serene outdoor setting.

Exterior View of Historic Home

A large, classic American home painted in a soft gray with white trim accents nestled among mature leafless trees, suggesting early spring or late fall. The architecture includes steeply pitched gabled roofs with exposed rafters and ornamental brackets supporting the eaves. Multiple tall brick chimneys rise above the roofline, adding a stately touch. Diamond-pane windows provide historic charm, while a stone stepping path winds through neatly trimmed greenery and bushes leading to a covered entryway on the left side. The home faces a scenic waterfront, enhancing its serene and elegant appeal.

Exterior Side View

A classic American home with pale blue wooden siding complemented by white trim and detailed ornamental brackets under the eaves. The steeply pitched roof is covered in dark shingles, topped with three tall brick chimneys capped in a shiny material. Multiple windows with white diamond-shaped muntins create a distinctive historic aesthetic. The house is set on a gently sloping plot with a well-kept lawn, surrounded by leafless trees suggesting early spring or late autumn. A small brick addition on the side contrasts with the wood siding. The distant view includes a body of water, enhancing the scenic, tranquil atmosphere.

Outdoor Patio Area

A spacious outdoor patio alongside the house presents a classic blend of natural stone flooring and a stone half-wall bordering the area. The exterior of the home combines white-painted wood siding with red brick columns framing large arched windows, offering a historic architectural touch. Traditional lantern-style wall lights add character and charm. Mature trees and manicured bushes set a natural, peaceful backdrop. A small black wrought-iron table with matching chairs sits at the far end of the patio, perfect for enjoying the outdoors in a tranquil, scenic setting.

Screened Porch with Waterfront View

Floor-to-ceiling arched windows and screen doors provide an expansive view of a serene waterfront, blending indoor comfort with outdoor beauty. The porch’s ceiling is painted white with beadboard paneling, lending a classic, airy feel. Red brick columns punctuate the white walls, adding warm, historic texture. Light blue painted wooden flooring complements the soft natural light filtering through. Wicker furniture arranged around a glass-topped table invites relaxation, while lush green ferns and white orchids bring freshness and life to the space. Elegant hanging lantern-style light fixtures enhance the vintage yet cozy ambiance.

Living Room Fireplace

Centered around a classic arched brick fireplace, this living room blends historic charm with elegant design. Dark wood trim frames the room and supports a second-floor balcony with lattice railing, enhancing architectural depth. A large gold-framed mirror and brass urns sit symmetrically atop the mantle. Two plush cream leather armchairs face a dark wood coffee table adorned with a vase of fresh flowers and decorative ceramics. The space features soft white walls contrasted by warm wood flooring and a mix of antique and vintage furnishings, creating a refined and inviting atmosphere. A brass chandelier hangs overhead, adding to the period ambiance.

Living Room and Library

Bright and airy living room with expansive windows overlooking a lake, flooding the space with natural light. The room has a classic charm with white upholstery on the sofa and armchairs contrasted by a dark wood coffee table on an ornate, patterned area rug. Soft blue and cream tones dominate, accented with pale blue throw pillows. Crown molding and dark wood lattice railings guard the open second-floor balcony above. Rich wooden trim frames the entry to an adjacent library area filled with built-in bookshelves, red velvet antique chairs, and a tasteful traditional rug, blending comfort with timeless elegance.

Kitchen and Breakfast Nook

Bright and airy kitchen with white cabinetry and marble countertops, centered around a detailed island that includes built-in appliances. The cabinetry extends to the ceiling, offering ample storage with glass-front doors showcasing a blue and white plate collection. Warm wooden floors contrast with the white walls and furniture. A cozy breakfast nook features a wooden table with white lattice-backed chairs cushioned in soft blue, sitting atop a striped rug. Traditional decorative elements, such as a brass chandelier, a vintage clock, and porcelain urns, add a historic charm. Natural light floods through a large multi-pane window above the farmhouse sink.

Kitchen Island and Breakfast Nook

A bright kitchen dominated by crisp white cabinetry and walls, highlighting intricate molding and carved corbels on the island. The island countertop is marble, coordinating with the marble backsplash behind the built-in stove area, which features a decorative metal piece mounted on the backsplash. Stainless steel appliances provide a modern contrast. Blue and white porcelain jars and plates add a classic touch of color and historic charm. Adjacent to the kitchen is a cozy breakfast nook with white wicker chairs topped with blue cushions around a round wooden table on a blue-and-white striped rug. Large multi-pane windows flood the space with natural light, framing views of the garden outside. Elegant brass chandelier and pendant lighting fixtures enhance the sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere, blending traditional elegance with functional design.

Kitchen Sink Area

A bright and elegant kitchen corner characterized by white cabinetry with classic raised-panel doors and polished chrome knobs. A farmhouse-style apron sink sits beneath a set of six-paned windows that allow ample natural light to flood the space, revealing a wooded outdoor view. The white marble countertops add a refined luxury, complemented by the wooden floor that introduces warmth. Above the sink, a vintage wooden clock offers a nostalgic touch. Blue and white porcelain pitchers and a framed artwork provide decorative contrast. The kitchen also includes built-in stainless steel appliances and a polished brass scale on the countertop.

Formal Dining Room

Elegant formal dining room centered around a polished wooden table surrounded by eight intricately carved chairs with striped upholstery. The room is brightened by natural light flowing through three symmetrically arranged windows featuring diamond-patterned panes. A stately crystal chandelier hangs above the table, contributing to the sophisticated ambiance. The bold red Persian rug with detailed motifs adds warmth and color to the wooden floor. Classic touches include an ornately framed fireplace on the left, antique framed paintings adorning the white walls, and a tall black china cabinet with decorative gold accents on the right, displaying fine china. French doors add an element of openness to the space.

Living Room Seating Area

Bright white walls and built-in bookshelves create a classic ambiance, filled with antique books and decorative ceramics. A vibrant settee and matching chair, upholstered in deep pink velvet with tufted backs, serve as the room’s focal point. The dark wood carved desk with intricate designs contrasts with the modern glass coffee table centralized on a large, patterned Persian rug featuring soft blue and cream tones. Windows with diamond-pane detailing flood the room with natural light, complemented by a sparkling crystal chandelier overhead. The corner fireplace with red brick and traditional mantel adds warmth and historic charm to the space.

Sunroom Overlooking Water

The space includes a bright sunroom with expansive glass walls providing panoramic views of a tranquil body of water and surrounding trees. The room blends natural materials, showcasing wicker furniture with light pastel cushions in cream and blue hues. White painted beadboard ceiling and crisp white walls contrast against exposed red brick columns framing the large windows, adding architectural character. The floor is a muted gray wood which complements the soft, coastal-inspired color palette. A glass-topped wicker coffee table holds a decorative white ceramic jar, while a ceiling pendant light adds a vintage touch. The airy design invites relaxation while connecting indoors to the scenic outdoors.

Sunroom with Sitting Area

Bright white walls and ceiling with beadboard paneling create a fresh, airy atmosphere. Large windows with diamond muntins line the left wall, enhancing natural light. The floor is painted gray wood, with exposed red brick pillars adding a rustic, historic charm. A glass-top table with white wicker legs sits near cozy wicker chairs with cream cushions, accented by green potted plants and a white orchid. Further inside, a second table with wicker seating provides a relaxed dining space. Arched doors and large glass sliding doors open to an outdoor patio filled with natural wood and metal furniture, emphasizing seamless indoor-outdoor flow.

Covered Porch Dining Area

Large covered porch with light blue painted wood flooring and white beadboard ceiling. Walls are painted white with shiplap paneling, creating a classic, coastal farmhouse feel. A glass-top dining table framed with wicker and natural-toned rattan is surrounded by six cushioned wicker armchairs. The porch is enclosed with large glass windows and arched openings supported by red brick columns, offering expansive views of a lake and surrounding trees. Decorative hanging lanterns provide warm lighting. A framed botanical art piece adorns the wall near a set of French doors with diamond-shaped mullions, adding historic charm and elegance.

Upper Landing Balcony

A richly crafted upper landing balcony features dark, polished wood with lattice-patterned railings adding a classic charm. Strong wooden beams stretch across the ceiling, contrasting the crisp white planked panels above. The balcony overlooks an elegant lower level with a large brass chandelier hanging below, visible through the open space. White walls and door frames highlight the surrounding rooms, where wood-paneled doors with diamond-shaped glass inserts add historic character. Natural light filters through diamond-paned windows in the background, complementing the timeless architectural details and warm wood tones throughout the space.

Living Room Details

A vaulted ceiling painted white brightens the living room, accentuating its spaciousness and openness. The wide windows with diamond-patterned panes allow ample natural light, framed by simple white trim. A large, richly patterned Persian-style area rug anchors the seating area, adding warm reds, blues, and cream tones to the space. The central wooden chest serves as a rustic coffee table, surrounded by a striped upholstered sofa with white and patterned cushions. Antique wooden furniture, including a desk, side tables, and a grand piano, brings traditional charm. The red upholstered armchair and unique antler chandelier add character and contrast while maintaining a classic aesthetic.

Bedroom Interior

Softly lit bedroom with warm, textured grasscloth wallpaper creating an inviting, cozy atmosphere. A brass bed frame with classic vertical bars anchors the room, dressed in crisp white bedding layered with a beige throw for subtle contrast. Dark wood furniture adds depth, including a narrow side table with turned legs supporting a white ceramic lamp, and a matching dresser topped with varied decorative accessories. Two large windows with distinctive diamond muntins frame serene outdoor views, allowing natural light to fill the space. The hardwood floor is softened by a neutral area rug, balancing traditional and natural elements harmoniously.

Luxurious Bathroom Interior

Green marble flooring extends throughout this expansive bathroom, centered around a raised bathtub with matching green marble surround and a gentle curved step. The bath is positioned beneath large stained glass windows which blend classic elegance with natural light. White walls create a crisp contrast to the intense marble hues and highlight gold fixtures, including a traditional vanity accompanied by an ornate gold-framed mirror. Twin tall candles and a decorative potted plant add warmth and a touch of nature. The white sanitary fixtures and unique vintage-style mirrors complete the refined historic aesthetic.

Bathroom Vanity and Window

A small bathroom corner with vintage flair displays intricately patterned tiles in white, yellow, and orange with delicate green vines covering the wall and floor. The wooden vanity supports a glossy black countertop with a unique gold basin, complemented by gold faucet fixtures. A large round mirror with a gold frame adds elegance above the sink. The toilet is positioned near a wall with a gold toilet paper holder. Two towels and a candle rest on a white side table next to a window featuring white wooden framing, allowing natural light to brighten the space. An exposed brick wall adds rustic contrast to the otherwise ornamental atmosphere.

Powder Room Details

Dark wood paneling envelops the small, intimate powder room, creating a warm, historic ambiance. A black marble countertop with gold veining sits atop a black wooden vanity, which includes a white porcelain sink with vintage brass fixtures. Above the sink, a large ornate gold-framed mirror adds an elegant touch while reflecting light from the diamond-paned window opposite. Pictures framed in black and gold hang on the wall, complementing the décor. A polished brass towel rack holds a neatly folded white towel, and the window provides a serene view of the natural landscape outside, allowing natural light to brighten the space subtly.

Upper Balcony Overlooking Living Room

Dark wood beams and latticework create a rich contrast against the white paneled ceiling and walls, highlighting the craftsmanship of historic design. The balcony with its intricately patterned railing runs along the perimeter, offering views down into the bright living room filled with large multi-pane windows. Light floods the room from below, accentuating the grandeur of the tall ceiling and the suspended antique brass chandelier. Two doorways lead off from the balcony, suggesting access to adjacent rooms, and a classic framed landscape painting adds a subtle touch of color and traditional decor to the mostly neutral palette.

Playroom Train Table

White walls and ceiling create a bright, clean atmosphere in this attic space with sloped ceilings. The focal point is a large built-in train table with a model train set, surrounded by ample white cabinetry featuring open shelving and closed storage with black handles. The floor contrasts with warm, rich hardwood planks, adding a historic charm. Small windows with diamond-patterned panes allow natural light. A single ceiling light hung by a chain centers above the train table. The room communicates a nostalgic blend of functional storage and playful vintage interests.

Cozy Attic Bedroom

A small attic bedroom with sloped ceilings painted in crisp white, creating an airy and bright atmosphere. Two diamond-patterned windows allow natural light to fill the space. The bed is dressed in white linens layered with a soft cream throw and a beige ruffled bed skirt with polka dots. White wicker nightstands with glass tops flank the bed, each topped with a textured white ceramic lamp featuring gold accents. A natural woven rug covers the hardwood floor, adding warmth and texture. Cushions and a wicker basket in the corner complete the cozy, cottage-style aesthetic.

Listing Agent: Michael A. Omedes of Michael Alexander Properties via Zillow